
Taryn Simon, Chapter I, A Living Man Declared Dead and Other Chapters I-XVIII
Taryn Simon has spent her career to date investigating documentary and archival aspects of photography. She took photographs of items seized by customs agents over four days at JFK airport for her 2009 series Contraband. The Innocents documented people who served time in prison for violent crimes they did not commit, questioning the idea of the photograph as eyewitness and credible evidence. (For a different – and doggedly detailed– investigation of this topic, dip into filmmaker Errol Morris’s book Believing is Seeing: Observations on the Mysteries of Photography.)
In A Living Man Declared Dead and Other Chapters, at the Museum of Modern Art through September 3, Simon uses a combination of portraiture, photographs and other ephemera (what she calls the footnote section), and text to explore identity by tracing the bloodlines of 18 different groups (nine are on view at MoMA). These include a family whose members were victims of genocide in Bosnia, a healer in Kenya with nine wives, four members of the same family in Uttar Pradesh, India, who discovered that they had been declared dead in the local land registry (the chapter from which the project takes its title), and rabbits intentionally infected with a lethal virus in Australia to control the rabbit population. There is a lot that’s compelling, both visually and conceptually, about the project, but it doesn't err on the side of accessibility. The grid of rabbits looks great on the wall, but it strikes an odd note in a project that seems to be about the messy mix of biology, history and autonomy that shapes people as individuals.

Taryn Simon, Excert from Chapter VII, A Living Man Declared Dead and Other Chapters
“For me,” Simon told the New York Times when the series was on view at the Tate in London last year, “it’s about those areas that are less speakable in a way. It’s not about forming an equation that arrives at an answer, but lots of questions, and disorientation.” There are, maybe, a few too many unanswered questions, but Simon is nothing if not ambitious in her exploration of the how photographs function, not just on the white walls of museums and galleries.
Having said that, she was also quite specific about how the work was installed in the museum: very white walls and very bright lights. Nothing soft or atmospheric, but rather a spare and lab-like atmosphere that highlighted the fact that the photographs on view are part of a taxonomy. The subjects all sit in nearly identical poses, in front of a plain, cream-colored background (the “non-place,” as Simon has called it). Nobody smiles, or displays any other emotion. The photographs, which are displayed in a gird, call to mind official documents – I.D. cards or mug shots – and like her Innocents series, they question the idea of a photograph as a reliable marker of identity.

Taryn Simon, Excerpt from Chapter III, A Living Man Declared Dead and Other Chapters
Alongside the portraits are texts identifying each person and giving a brief description of each family, or bloodline. The other visual elements – which range from photographs of the interior of an orphanage, to maps, to an image of a bit of graffiti – amplify our understanding only partially, and I imagine that’s intentional. Simon is not out to provide answers. Like a number of thoughtful, ambitious contemporary photographers– Doug Rickard or Zhang Dali, for example, who were in New Photography 2011 at MoMA – she explores the porous boundaries between documentary and fine art photography. It’s a fertile place to work, but the results can sometimes be more puzzling than persuasive.
By Jean Dykstra



















